Zeffirelli version of Hamlet is Medieval based. For this reason the sets were much darker compared to Branagh's. This immediately threw me off. I was not as drawn or interested as I had been for the first film. Moreover, the acting for me fell flat. Gibson as Hamlet was not convincing and I often found myself bored. The ghost scene was anticlimactic and unappealing. There was little emotion shared between the two characters and I was not as enchanted during this scene as I had been for Branagh's. In my opinion, this subtle approach to Hamlet's first ghost scene was unsuccessful.
Of all three visions, Almereyda adaptation of Hamlet is the one I remember least. The film is set in Modern day Manhattan but uses the same dialogue as the play. While watching this scene I felt very underwhelmed.The acting, for the most part, was mediocre and the contemporary setting clashed with the dialogue. In my opinion, this was the worst film of the three. If I were to interpret this scene through film myself, my approach would be similar to Branagh's. I would use dramatic lighting and settings to convey the importance of the scene.
Gives a good description about all of the scenes and a lot of details.
ReplyDelete